Comparison of assays measuring extracellular vesicle-tissue factor in plasma samples: Communication from the ISTH SSC Subcommittee on Vascular Biology

BACKGROUND: Scientific and clinical interest in extracellular vesicles (EVs) is growing. EVs that expose tissue factor (TF) bind factor VII/VIIa and can trigger coagulation. Highly procoagulant TF-exposing EVs are detectable in the circulation in various diseases, such as sepsis, COVID-19 or cancer. Many in-house and commercially available assays have been developed to measure EV-TF activity and antigen but only a few studies have compared some of these assays. The ISTH SSC Subcommittee on Vascular Biology initiated a multicenter study to compare the sensitivity, specificity and reproducibility of these assays. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Platelet-depleted plasma samples were prepared from blood of healthy donors. The plasma samples were spiked either with EVs from human milk, or EVs from TF-positive and TF-negative cell lines. Plasma was also prepared from whole human blood with or without LPS stimulation. Twenty-one laboratories measured EV-TF activity and antigen in the prepared samples using their own assays representing 18 functional and 9 antigenic assays. RESULTS: There was a large variability in the absolute values for the different EV-TF activity and antigen assays. Activity assays had higher specificity and sensitivity compared to antigen assays. In addition, there was a large intra-assay and inter-assay variability. Functional assays that used a blocking anti-TF antibody or immunocapture were the most specific and sensitive. Activity assays that used immunocapture had a lower coefficient of variation compared to assays that isolated EVs by high-speed centrifugation. CONCLUSION: Based on this multicenter study, we recommend measuring EV-TF using a functional assay in the presence of an anti-TF antibody.

• Bonifay, A.
• Mackman, N.
• Hisada, Y.
• Sachetto, A. T. A.
• Hau, C.
• Gray, E.
• Hogwood, J.
• Aharon, A.
• Badimon, L.
• Barile, L.
• Baudar, J.
• Beckmann, L.
• Benedikter, B.
• Bolis, S.
• Bouriche, T.
• Brambilla, M.
• Burrello, J.
• Camera, M.
• Campello, E.
• Ettelaie, C.
• Faille, D.
• Featherby, S.
• Franco, C.
• Guldenpfennig, M.
• Hansen, J. B.
• Judicone, C.
• Kim, Y.
• Kristensen, S. R.
• Laakmann, K.
• Langer, F.
• Latysheva, N.
• Lucien, F.
• de Menezes, E. M.
• Mullier, F.
• Norris, P.
• Nybo, J.
• Orbe, J.
• Osterud, B.
• Paramo, J. A.
• Radu, C. M.
• Roncal, C.
• Samadi, N.
• Snir, O.
• Suades, R.
• Wahlund, C.
• Chareyre, C.
• Abdili, E.
• Martinod, K.
• Thaler, J.
• Dignat-George, F.
• Nieuwland, R.
• Lacroix, R.