Benchmarking whole exome sequencing in the German network for personalized medicine

INTRODUCTION: Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) has emerged as an efficient tool in clinical cancer diagnostics to broaden the scope from panel-based diagnostics to screening of all genes and enabling robust determination of complex biomarkers in a single analysis. METHODS: To assess concordance, six formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue specimens and four commercial reference standards were analyzed by WES as matched tumor-normal DNA at 21 NGS centers in Germany, each employing local wet-lab and bioinformatics. Somatic and germline variants, copy-number alterations (CNAs), and complex biomarkers were investigated. Somatic variant calling was performed in 494 diagnostically relevant cancer genes. The raw data were collected and re-analyzed with a central bioinformatic pipeline to separate wet- and dry-lab variability. RESULTS: The mean positive percentage agreement (PPA) of somatic variant calling was 76 % while the positive predictive value (PPV) was 89 % in relation to a consensus list of variants found by at least five centers. Variant filtering was identified as the main cause for divergent variant calls. Adjusting filter criteria and re-analysis increased the PPA to 88 % for all and 97 % for the clinically relevant variants. CNA calls were concordant for 82 % of genomic regions. Homologous recombination deficiency (HRD), tumor mutational burden (TMB), and microsatellite instability (MSI) status were concordant for 94 %, 93 %, and 93 % of calls, respectively. Variability of CNAs and complex biomarkers did not decrease considerably after harmonization of the bioinformatic processing and was hence attributed mainly to wet-lab differences. CONCLUSION: Continuous optimization of bioinformatic workflows and participating in round robin tests are recommended.

• Menzel, M.
• Martis-Thiele, M.
• Goldschmid, H.
• Ott, A.
• Romanovsky, E.
• Siemanowski-Hrach, J.
• Seillier, L.
• Brüchle, N. O.
• Maurer, A.
• Lehmann, K. V.
• Begemann, M.
• Elbracht, M.
• Meyer, R.
• Dintner, S.
• Claus, R.
• Meier-Kolthoff, J. P.
• Blanc, E.
• Möbs, M.
• Joosten, M.
• Benary, M.
• Basitta, P.
• Hölscher, F.
• Tischler, V.
• Groß, T.
• Kutz, O.
• Prause, R.
• William, D.
• Horny, K.
• Goering, W.
• Sivalingam, S.
• Borkhardt, A.
• Blank, C.
• Junk, S. V.
• Yasin, L.
• Moskalev, E. A.
• Carta, M. G.
• Ferrazzi, F.
• Tögel, L.
• Wolter, S.
• Adam, E.
• Matysiak, U.
• Rosenthal, T.
• Dönitz, J.
• Lehmann, U.
• Schmidt, G.
• Bartels, S.
• Hofmann, W.
• Hirsch, S.
• Dikow, N.
• Göbel, K.
• Banan, R.
• Hamelmann, S.
• Fink, A.
• Ball, M.
• Neumann, O.
• Rehker, J.
• Kloth, M.
• Murtagh, J.
• Hartmann, N.
• Jurmeister, P.
• Mock, A.
• Kumbrink, J.
• Jung, A.
• Mayr, E. M.
• Jacob, A.
• Trautmann, M.
• Kirmse, S.
• Falkenberg, K.
• Ruckert, C.
• Hirsch, D.
• Immel, A.
• Dietmaier, W.
• Haack, T.
• Marienfeld, R.
• Fürstberger, A.
• Niewöhner, J.
• Gerstenmaier, U.
• Eberhardt, T.
• Greif, P. A.
• Appenzeller, S.
• Maurus, K.
• Doll, J.
• Jelting, Y.
• Jonigk, D.
• Märkl, B.
• Beule, D.
• Horst, D.
• Wulf, A. L.
• Aust, D.
• Werner, M.
• Reuter-Jessen, K.
• Ströbel, P.
• Auber, B.
• Sahm, F.
• Merkelbach-Bruse, S.
• Siebolts, U.
• Roth, W.
• Lassmann, S.
• Klauschen, F.
• Gaisa, N. T.
• Weichert, W.
• Evert, M.
• Armeanu-Ebinger, S.
• Ossowski, S.
• Schroeder, C.
• Schaaf, C. P.
• Malek, N.
• Schirmacher, P.
• Kazdal, D.
• Pfarr, N.
• Budczies, J.
• Stenzinger, A.